“Clayface” - Thoughts
So I saw the new DC Studios, R-rated Clayface film this week… Let’s get into it.
Now, so far I’ve really appreciated the revamped, rebooted, James Gunnified DCU… Granted, I haven’t seen Supergirl, but Lanterns was quite quality in its story, casting, and construction. And don’t even get me started on the Gunn written and directed Superman (2025); that film is gold. But, Clayface is something else entirely. This movie seems completely disconnected from what we’ve seen so far in the new DCU. This movie has no problem being gross, vengeful, or over-the-top. And, not only is it those things, but it also feels quite real, grounded (for a comic book movie), and simple.
At roughly an hour and 40 minutes with change, Clayface, from Director James Watkins, is by no means ground-breaking. But in that runtime, the film manages to showcase some nice body horror, present some hilarious jabs at Hollywood, and make a relatively forgotten, gross B-list Batman villain sympathetic, in a way. With acclaimed horror writer Mike Flanagan at the writers’ table for this one, I knew it was unlikely that we would get something bad. However, DC Studios has released so many mediocre if not bad movies, that it’s hard to really go into a release with great expectations.
The story isn’t exactly hard to follow, and it seems rather straightforward for a Flanagan screenplay. But that doesn’t make it bad in the slightest.
Spoilers Ahead!
We see an up-and-coming actor, named Matt Hagan, get nominated for an academy award, proving to all his doubters and himself that he can make it out of a sketchy, crime-ridden neighborhood. He goes to celebrate at a well-known nightclub in Gotham and then makes the poor choice to sleep with a mob boss’s girlfriend. He wakes up to find the mob boss there at the foot of the bed, and he cuts off several parts of his face. After more accusations fly towards Matt, some where he’s accused of drugging the girl, he decides to spend all his money attempting to fix his face so that he can get his old life back. However, Gotham just seems to take advantage of him more and more, and he ultimately ends up in a rundown, roach-infested apartment with no work. Depressed, he decides to go out on a limb and reach out to a down-on-her-luck stem cell researcher who is working with cells that can help regenerate damaged tissue. They both cross medical testing guidelines and begin work on Matt‘s face with a drug unapproved for human trials. This drug is successful at first, and Hagan goes to a movie premiere of a movie that he was kicked out of to flex his new face. But, as he’s there, his face begins to fall off, and he begins to panic. He runs back to the researcher, and he impulsively inject his face with more of the drug. At this point, Matt begins to become somewhat of an unstoppable force of artificial power, and he starts to go on a rampage, killing everyone that wronged him.
It’s a revenge story. A very simple one too. Simple, just like vanilla and chocolate ice cream, the most popular, best-selling flavors in the United States. I want to applaud that because I too often go to comic book movies that attempt to shove every franchise character into the two-hour runtime. It’s exhausting to have to keep track of that much as a viewer, especially when watching the kind of cinema that Scorcese called “theme park rides”.
This movie earns its R-rating too. Not only is there PLENTY of blood and grossness, but there’s also a few sex-based scenes as well.
Overall, I find Clayface to be simple, yet a refreshingly good time. Make sure to check it out.
“The Social Reckoning” - Thoughts
Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning (2026), his new, standalone, ‘spiritual successor’ to Fincher’s The Social Network (2010) is interesting, to say the least.
What Sorkin Means to Me
Sorkin has long been one of my favorite screenwriters. He’s a big inspiration for me. From his feature-length scripts like A Few Good Men (1992) and Steve Jobs (2015) to his television work with The West Wing (1999-2006) and The Newsroom (2012-14), he really makes me believe I can do it all as a writer.
Craft-wise, Sorkin’s writing is crisp, fast-paced, quip-heavy, and simply put, smart. He gets what makes technology and public service jobs so interesting to the people that choose them, and he truly understands how to give that feeling to the audience. His “walk and talk” shots have become a staple to his game, somehow immersing the viewer in heavy exposition and limited action without losing their interest. He does his research and nobly seeks to both educate and entertain the masses. I really don’t understand the hate he gets…
My favorite script of his is The Social Network. That movie, directed by David Fincher, is easily one of the best of the 21st century, and Sorkin’s words really give that story its vibrant, beating heart.
Light Praise, Initial Thoughts - Spoilers Ahead
But enough glazing from me, let’s get this out of the way… I knew this wasn’t going to be anywhere near the quality of The Social Network as that movie is a group effort in flawlessness on all fronts (acting, directing, sound design, score, script, etc.). But, honestly, I didn’t need it to be another The Social Network… All I wanted was to see a meaningful story, which this story is… Ish.
The Social Reckoning is about famed Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen and her collaboration with investigative journalist Jeff Horwitz in efforts to expose a series of her employer’s darkest secrets. At its simplest, this is a David versus Goliath story about doing the right thing, standing up for one’s principles, and protecting the voiceless.
Our protagonists successfully stand up to the seemingly invincible members of the 1% (specifically Mark Zuckerberg), proving to the audience that its possible to land blows in the face of all odds. This is a hopeful movie, and I believe, during times like these, we need these more than ever.
The foundation and ideas for a great movie are here, but I think its execution may have been botched.
The Issues
There are a few decisions Sorkin makes that I find demeaning as an audience member. If you haven’t seen the film, the story is in two parts (two time periods). We have the investigative journalism side of the story that takes place from 2019 through mid 2020, and we have the 2021-rooted legal/backlash side of the story that revolves around Zuckerberg being prepped for a trial.
You’d think that because both parts revolve around different characters, that we wouldn’t need to tell the audience where we’re at in the story. But, Sorkin does this anyway, placing a “2019” or a “2021” everytime we switch to a different side of the narrative. It’s as if Sorkin believes the audience isn’t capable of following this basic narrative switch, and that’s mildly insulting.
Script-wise, the film is way too concerned with the investigative journalism side of this narrative and chooses to somewhat neglect the better part of the story - the Mark Zuckerberg “January 6th” part. This backlash isn’t emphasized enough, and I feel we missed out on some quality story beats because of it.
Now, I do want to praise that Mark Zuckerberg aspect to this. Everything that happens in the “2021” section is great. Watching Facebook’s higher-ups and legal team panic while Zuckerberg ego-trips is wildly enjoyable, and Bill Burr’s character constantly calling him a piece of s**t is the cherry on top.
But, the Mikey Madison/Jeremy Allen-White side of things just doesn’t have the stakes to make it interesting… It’s a real shame because I know its possible to get that kind of story right. Look at the Academy Award-winning film Spotlight (2016); it holds legitimate tension for the majority of its runtime and doesn’t fall off the gas. I don’t think I ever felt as though those two were in legitimate danger.
It’s clear Sorkin did his research, and he goes overboard with this in the dialogue. There are WAY too many statistics thrown around for the audience to both keep up with and care about. I get that it’s probably closer to reality as reporters probably need statistics more than anecdotes, but still… Add some bite to the words we hear.
Final Thoughts
Unfortunately, The Social Reckoning fails to really touch the framework and flare of its predecessor despite having a great foundation. It’s got the ingredients and shows legitimate promise, but I think Sorkin may want to stay in the writer’s chair from here on out… Mildly squandered.